New WCA Member Discounts are Available! Click for more information

President’s Response to Free Press Article

Posted on: April 28, 2014  |  

The Minister is right in his claim that my figures were inaccurate (Cottagers want answers, April 5, 2014), but he remains dead wrong on the significance of the error and the meaning of the data.

First, in the interest of fairness, our attempt to correctly state sources of revenue from cottagers was in error, but it was what in tennis is called a “forced error”. In all the pages of financial data the Ministry provides on its web site, nowhere is there any information on sources of revenue.  So to find out how much the government collects in lease payments from cottagers, we had to turn to the annual report  for 2012/13 of the Crown Lands and Property Agency. On  page 11 of that report, we found an entry for revenue collected from Vacation Home Leases and Permits, our source for the figure of $4,021,000 in cottager lease payments in our table. We had no way of knowing that this figure blended the $1.7 million figure for service fees with what should correctly have been specified as $2,321,000 in revenue from leases and permits. As a result we overstated the contribution of cottagers to Government revenues.

However, our main point stands. On recalculation, Cottagers still provide an excess of  revenue over expenses to the Government amounting to $1,073,791.00  per year. So it is still the case that we are subsidizing the province, and not the other way around.

This is contrary to the original statement of the Minister, when he claimed that the province was subsidizing the cottager “fat cats” (as I recall your reporters reported his accusation). But I won’t be holding my breath for a retraction on this key point by the Minister, since he appears to be girding his loins for a legal battle. Nor can we expect to see a revision of the Ministerial policy to withhold critical information on costs and revenues in the Parks, despite their obligation to do so. But I do still have hopes that reporting by the Free Press return to its standard of holding the government’s toes to the fire, rather than rewarming their dubious arguments.


Read the Free Press article here:

Leave a Reply

All News Categories

LOST DOG"We are missing our dog from our home- we have 2 they are always together but 1 randomly disappeared- her name is Foxy, she's just over 2yrs old , has all shots- rabies etc no microchip. We live off Zamec rd in Hadashville mb hwy 11 close to hwy 1. 204-869-3236- Michelle" ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook
View on Facebook
Question from a Cottager – “Does anybody know if there is a notary in the south Whiteshell?” ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook
Caddy Air Field – Manitoba Historical SocietyDuring the Great Depression of the 1930s, the Canadian federal government employed able-bodied, unemployed men to build public infrastructure. In return for their labour, each man was provided with food, shelter, and 20 cents per day. In Manitoba, three construction gangs worked in the Whiteshell Forest Reserve (today’s Whiteshell Provincial Park) to build roads to enable the development of tourism in this part of the province. Between Fall 1933 and Spring 1934, one hundred men from the Caddy Lake Relief Camp, under the supervision of Col. Logie Armstrong from the Department of National Defense, built an emergency airfield at this site about 1.5 miles west of the Ontario border. ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook
Good morning, we found a small water craft (paddle boat) adrift in Big Whiteshell Lake. It was found floating in the middle of the lake no where near a cabin. I was wondering if you could post something for me? If they can identify what it is then we will know it is going to the rightful owner. They can message me to identify what it is and for pick up information. Or call me at 1 (204) 348-3294. ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook

Recent Instagram Posts