New WCA Member Discounts are Available! Click for more information

Park vs Municipal Fees

Posted on: November 4, 2014  |  

Unraveling the Mystery:

Assessment, Taxation, Park Service Fees, and Crown Land Rent

There are two cottage worlds in Manitoba. Cottagers who lease lots in provincial parks and cottagers who own titled land within a municipality (or in a very few cases, within a provincial park). The provincial government has raised the issue of fairness when they have compared occupancy costs between these two worlds.

The Municipal World

The cottage lot in a municipality is taxed under the authority of the Municipal Assessment Act (MAA).  The municipality and the local school division have the authority to levy property taxes. The amounts levied must be based on a cash requirement determined by annual budgets which are public documents revealing all planned expenditures and all expected revenues by source.

The level at which individuals pay these taxes is determined by an evidence based property assessment using a market value (MV) established by the comparison of sales records of similar property over the period between re-assessments.

Property taxes are calculated on a portioned value of the property assessment.  The provincial Assessment Act regulates portioning of market value with residential class property taxed on 45% of market value assessment.  Hence, a market value assessment of $150,000 would pay taxes on a portioned value assessment of $67,500.

Assessment data is revised every two years using a computer model of all sales.  The data is public and available without cost on the websites of the Provincial Municipal Assessor and the City of Winnipeg Assessor.

In addition to the care with which the assessments are performed, there also exists a well-developed appeals process if an owner feels the assessment is incorrect.  First, an informal discussion with an assessor is available.  The owner is not required to employ an accredited real estate appraiser.  If no agreement is reached the formal process of appeal to the Board of Revision is available.  A final appeal can subsequently be made to the Municipal Board.  The formal processes provide an accessible, impartial, quasi-judicial forum.  Throughout these processes, information is freely available, shared, and without cost to the appellant.

 

The Provincial Parks World

 

Cottagers on leased land pay two rates.  The Park District Service Fee (PDSF) is supposed to cover the annual costs of capital, administration, and municipal type services specific to an individual lot.  The rate is calculated based upon the actual costs of the previous year’s services adjusted by a shares formula.

The park lessee is also subject to crown land rent. There is no stated cash requirement for the rent as all service costs are supposed to have been paid by the PDSF.  Crown land rent is a direct contribution to the general revenue of Manitoba and is not dedicated for use in parks.  The amount of this contribution is determined arbitrarily by government and is calculated by the application of a percentage rate on an equivalent market value for crown land in a similar region.  Equivalent crown land market value is not rated on individual properties, but is assessed on a categorical basis by park district and lot type.

Cottagers will have noted a change in their land value assessment this year. The data and analytic process used to re-assess Crown land values from the former values derived in the 1980’s have not been available to the public. Nor was the rationale for the increase of the percentage rate which occurred incrementally from the 1980’s to 2000  ( a doubling, from 2% to 4%) been shared with public. This is a significant contrast to the open and cost free nature of municipal assessment information.

Cottagers are advised that this year they can appeal lot land value to Crown Lands and Property Agency (CLPA) if they have a report from an accredited appraiser with a different valuation.  This process is in significant contrast to an appeal of a municipal assessment.  Since CLPA has itself determined the Crown land equivalent market value and levies the rent and PDSF, it cannot provide the impartial appeal process available to municipal ratepayers through the Board of Revision or the Municipal Board.

Crown land market values were left unadjusted since the 1980’s until this year, when they have been substantially increased. Yet the pre-existing rental rate (4%) has been held constant. This has produced a massive increase in rent, starting in 2014 and according to the Ministry plan, destined to be phased in over ten years.  A simultaneous PDSF increase will be phased in over five years.  A promised maximum occupancy cost of $3000 will apparently be in force for four years ending with the 2017 invoice, although the official regulation showing the full 10-year phase in remains unamended.

It is interesting to note that if the PDSF in any year did not cover service costs then a draw could be made on provincial general revenue to balance the account.  Crown land rent contributes significantly to general revenue and is available to offset any shortfall in PDSF.  Unfortunately, government interpretations of the revenues received from cottagers do not recognize the contributions made by Crown land rent.

Let’s look at an example for a typical lakefront, road access cottage at West Hawk Lake:

The 2014 share of services cost for this site (PDSF) is $871.64. After the phase in rebate, the lessee cost for 2014 is $455.93

2014 Invoice Revenue

  • Boat house/dock lease                      $20.00
  • Rent (lease) after rebate                 $1320.00
  • PDSF after rebate                             $455.93
  • Total net of GST                             $1795.93

If we calculate the total revenue derived from this leasee and subtract the PDSF cost share ($1795.93 – $871.64= $924.29 gross surplus,;$924.29 less PDSF rebate of $415.71= $508.58),    we find that the total revenue collected on this invoice pays all service costs and contributes a net surplus of $508.58 to provincial general revenue. With about 900 cottages at West Hawk (most with comparable tax and service contributions), a net annual contribution to provincial general revenue of nearly $500,000 is generated from just this lake.

When the contribution of land rent is considered there does not appear to be any subsidy of cottager costs from the income and consumption taxes of Manitoba.

The Future

Continuing our example at West Hawk, we can expect PDSF to experience 3% inflation per year over ten years. PDSF in this example would be $1140 per year ten years from now. Land rents are forecast to change as values are reassessed, buildings are evaluated, and rental rates adjusted. Current land rent (un-rebated) is $6000. In ten years it is reasonable to assume that all caps, rebates, and phase-ins will have ended and that total annual occupancy cost for this example will be $7500 or more. In other words, lessees will experience increases on the order of 750% in the South Whiteshell. Rental revenue will begin to run well ahead of a PDSF which, presumably, will continue to pay all costs. Rental revenue will then contribute hugely to provincial general revenue.

The recent policy changes in PDSF and land rent are the result of a seven-year development process in Parks Branch. They advise that the process will continue a further five years to develop a valuation program for cottage buildings on leased land to be used in rent calculation. This kind of individual value based assessment of buildings has the potential to significantly increase the administrative cost component in PDSF.

Any further consideration of cottage lease revenues and the amount and calculation of Crown land rent, which by the way, the current government has promised, will only be acceptable if a joint process including meaningful direct stakeholder involvement is employed to develop new policy. Establishment of a process of this kind will need political direction, and cottagers should protect their interests by monitoring and helping to shape the directions proposed. Cottage lessees are strongly encouraged to contact their local MLA to arrange a personal meeting to discuss the policy development process and to encourage the establishment of a joint process to engage stakeholders in meaningful policy development.

2 responses to “Park vs Municipal Fees”

  1. John Ollivier says:

    As I said at the Annual General Meeting these Gov’t. proposals to further increase the Lease Fees will only drive out those large % of hard working middle class Manitobans from sustaining a cottage for their families . How can a family afford to pay $ 7500 a year , which excludes any utility costs , maintenance costs etc. ,in Lease fees for a cottage they only can use in most cases for 5-6 months of a year . The NDP Government who are obviously driving this quest for more revenue with their misleading data and arrogance should be ashamed.

    • Elin says:

      I really don’t unadestrnd why the leases are not being renewed long term. It seems pretty silly to me to evict a community that has been there through several generations because they are part of a provincial park. What and/or whom are they hurting remaining there? Seems to me that if they are leasing the properties it means some guaranteed revenue, and if no others are able to obtain leases other than the existing properties, progress into the natural environment won’t happen.

Leave a Reply

All News Categories

Hello WCA, Here are the new items for today. - Manitoba Hydro released information this afternoon regarding the expected continued high water flows on the Winnipeg River (we have provided the link below and some of the key lake points). The Winnipeg River is expected to crest between June 5-10. Please see www.hydro.mb.ca/corporate/facilities/water_levels/ to view the forecast.- The shoreline adjacent to the Pointe du Bois subdivision has been included in the 100 metre from shore prohibition on recreational motor boat use. Whiteshell Provincial Park: May 27, 2022 A local state of emergency has been declared for Whiteshell Provincial Park on May 20, 2022 due to rising water levels within the park. Developed areas at Betula Lake were closed on May 21, 2022. This closure area was expanded (May 24) to include Sylvia Lake, Otter Falls, Dorothy Lake, Barrier Bay and Nutimik Lake areas. No person should reside or enter into the closed area. Please visit the Manitoba Parks Website www.gov.mb.ca/sd/parks/ to see a map of the closure. This applies to all cottage subdivisions, commercial areas, campgrounds, group use, day use, recreational and picnic areas, playgrounds, trails, and beaches with within the order area. During the closure no person should reside or enter into the closure area of the park. Manitoba Hydro released information this afternoon regarding the expected continued high water flows on the Winnipeg River. Water continues to rise significantly along the lakes that make up the Winnipeg River system (Nutimik, Dorothy, Margaret, Eleanor, and Sylvia Lakes as well as Pointe du Bois) as water moves downstream from Lake of the Woods. Water levels rise quickly in these areas due to natural restrictions along the river. Please see www.hydro.mb.ca/corporate/facilities/water_levels/ to view the forecast. Manitoba Hydro is predicating an increase of water levels from the current high water over the next 10 to 14 days, as follows: • 6 inches upstream of Eight Foot Falls. • 10 inches in Nutimik Lake. • 9 inches in Dorothy Lake. • 11 inches in Margaret/Eleanor Lake. • 1 foot in Sylvia Lake. • 8 inches upstream of Silver Falls. The Winnipeg River is expected to crest between June 5-10. Rising water levels and rapidly evolving conditions pose a significant risk to public safety. Manitoba Parks continue to monitor safety and water levels inside the closure area, additional safety measures may be applied if required. Manitoba Parks has been contacting all permanent residents in the closure area. If you have not been contacted by Manitoba Parks staff to register, please call the parks line at 204-340-6769 and leave a message with your name, lot, block, subdivision, and ask to be added to the permanent residents list. You will then be called back to register. Water levels improvement are being seen in all areas south of the Winnipeg River. Falcon, West Hawk, Star, Caddy, Brereton, White, and Jessica Lakes are reporting a decrease today. One log was also inserted into the West Hawk Dam on May 26 to slow the downstream flow, this change will take a few days to positively impact Jessica and White Lake. Manitoba Parks staff are working in conjunction with staff from the department of Manitoba, Transportation and Infrastructure to monitor lake levels and adjust control structures where possible. This includes monitoring structures for blockages. Crescent Beach seawall at West Hawk is barricaded and closed. Pay attention to signage, and barricades. The travel lane has been moved away from the wall and is narrow in spots, please travel slowly. Cottages in the Crescent Beach, High Rock, McKenzie Beach, and Hunt Lake subdivisions should be aware of the potential for a re-route in the event of further damage to the seawall. Sandbags for filling and sand are available for cottage owners at: the 8 Foot Falls Road in Pointe du Bois, Jessica Lake at the garbage collection site, the parking lot across from Brereton Lake Resort, the West Hawk maintenance yard, and the causeway at Falcon Lake. There are a limited number of pre-filled bags at the Jessica Lake and Pointe du Bois depots. PR 307 from the west park entrance to the PR307/309 junction, and PR 312 near Caddy Lake is closed to all traffic. PR 309 near Meditation Lake is restricted to local traffic only. We encourage everyone to check manitoba511.ca before travelling. You can call 511 anywhere in Manitoba to get updates by phone. Water is present on several block roads throughout the park. White Lake Block 4 is closed to vehicle use. The following block roads should not be crossed in a smaller vehicle until the water recedes: High Rock Road at West Hawk, and Jessica Lake Block 5-6-7-8. Caution should be used when travelling through flooded areas. The following boat launches are closed in addition to those in the park closure area: 8 Foot Falls, Big Creek, White Lake, Jessica Lake, South Shore Big Whiteshell, and Toniata. West Hawk and Falcon Beach Campground Boat launches have been re-opened. Public can expect open launches to be without docks, high water is preventing repair and placement of docks throughout the park. Please use caution and courtesy when boating. All boat traffic should be cautious of debris and items submerged below the surface. Please be advised that you cannot visit the closed area of the park by boat. Access is not allowed to your cottage or recreational areas via the Winnipeg River. No landing in the closed area is allowed. Extreme caution should be used with travelling the upstream portion of the Winnipeg River (Pointe du Bois to Lamprey Falls). To minimize potential erosion caused by boat wakes, recreational motor boat restrictions are in place. Recreational motor boat traffic is prohibited from operating within 100 metres of the shoreline on: West Hawk, Falcon, Caddy, Star, Brereton, Jessica, White, Big Whiteshell, Betula, Nutimik, Dorothy, Margaret, Eleanor Lakes, and the shoreline adjacent to the Pointe du Bois subdivision in Whiteshell Provincial Park. When exiting or approaching the shoreline, boats should move directly out from land and avoid creating a wake. The following hiking trails are closed in addition to those in the park closure area: the Marsh Trail (between Falcon Lake Marina and Beach Campground), TransCanada Trail at Penniac Bay, and Hunt Lake. All backcountry campsites in Whiteshell Provincial park are closed due to flooding, high water conditions and frequently changing portage conditions. Campers should check the Manitoba Parks homepage for the status of campgrounds prior to coming to the park. Several campgrounds have full or partial closures. All campground in the closure area will remain closed until this portion of the park reopens (Dorothy Lake, Opapiskaw, Nutimik Lake, and Otter Falls). In addition, White Lake Campground is closed (seasonal and nightly) and nightly camping is closed in Big Whiteshell Campground. Phone Numbers/ Websites:• Parks info line for water, flood and closures: 204-340-6769 between 8am and 6pm daily. • To report an emergency please contact the RCMP via 911 if located in the South Whiteshell, 204-348-7177 in the North Whiteshell, and 204-345-8685 in Pointe du Bois. • Camping Information 1-888-482-2267 for the Parks Reservation Service. • Environment, Climate and Parks General inquiry line 1-800-214-6497. • Highway conditions: Manitoba511.ca • Manitoba Parks: manitobapark.com for a list of other closures.• Manitoba Hydro Water Flow New Release: www.hydro.mb.ca/articles/2022/05/manitoba_hydro_advises_extreme_caution_on_waterways/• DFA Information: www.gov.mb.ca/emo/dfa/residence.html, dfa@gov.mb.ca or by phone at 204-945-3050. ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook
Regular weekly Hydro report for Winnipeg River LakesNOTE: this is a 7 day forecast, the earlier one was 10-14 day - so the numbers are different ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook
Winnipeg River hydro report(Our regular Friday report expected in about an hour) ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook
Posted on Caddy lake page (Dennis Dyck) – “ Found floating on Caddy Lake; blue plastic barrel. Still has both bung caps installed, so likely used as a float support rather than a weight. A marathon canoe with a # 32 painted on it. A 5 gallon jerrycan If these items belong to you please pick them up at block 9, lot 25. Thanks ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook
Sheila Dancho – “I have lost two sections of stairs that look like these. Please post to your page. Thanks for your help. Contact info 2042663066 Sheila Dancho from The Nutimik Island” ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook

Recent Instagram Posts