New WCA Member Discounts are Available! Click for more information

Cottage Cost Comparisons

Posted on: November 4, 2014  |  

Cottage Occupancy Cost Comparisons:

Gimli, Lac du Bonnet, and Whiteshell

In its statements, the government has made claims that amount to slander with respect to cottagers being freeloaders, not paying their fair share, being subsidized by poor widows in Winnipeg etc etc. The WCA is fortunate to have members with expertise that allows the organization to read between the lines of the Ministry’s statements about their service fee and lease rate policies. On careful study, none of these outrageous claims of the government carry any weight. For example, here is an analysis of comparative Occupancy Costs in three regions of the province which reveals the emptiness of the Ministry’s claim that cottagers pay far less in occupancy costs than do landowners in neighboring or similar locations in the province.

“In the interpretation of recent changes in Park District Service Fee and Crown land rent the government has referenced the issue of fairness in comparing lessee costs to property taxes for owned cottage land in a municipality. Their claim has been that in setting new lease rates for cottagers, they are only bringing cottagers fees up to the levels of taxes paid in comparable Municipalities.

Currently, Whiteshell lessees pay rent on the equivalent Crown land market value for their lot and the building is disregarded due to cottager’s status as tenants rather than as owners.

Here are some interesting examples for land with roughly similar assessments:

Gimli Third Avenue (lakefront, road access)

2013 Assessment:

Land Market Value…………………. $190,600

Building Market Value………………. $26,900

 

Total:     Market Value………….    $217,500

Portioned Value………….. $97,880

 

2013 Taxes:

RM of Gimli                                 14.161 mills

Evergreen School Division                   11.506 mills

Total:                                           25.667 mills

 

Taxes:   Total   (0 .025667 x $97,880)=  $2512.30

(RM Only                                 $1386.00)

Total tax rate is 2.5667% expressed in percentage terms.

 

 

Lac du Bonnet

Roll # 302004.00

This property sold Nov. 15, 2011 for $300,000

2013 Assessment:

Land Market Value……………………. $141,000

Building Market Value………………….$163,800

Total:       Market Value……………….$304,900

Portioned Value …………..$137,205

 

2013 Taxes:

RM of Lac du Bonnet                         13.5 mills

Sunrise School Division                 14.9 mills

Total:                                                     28.4 mills

 

Taxes: Land only (as in park)

Total   .02836 x PV $63,496………… $1800.70

(Municipal only                      $857.20)

 

Taxes: Land and Building (as in RM)

Total   .02836 x PV $137,205…………. $3891.13

(Excluding School                    $1852.27)

 

Tax rate is 2.836% expressed in percentage terms.

 

 

West Hawk Lake (lakefront, road access)

 

Crown land equivalent market value $150,000

Rental rate                                   4% of value

 

Park District Service Fee                            $455.93

Land Rent                                                     $1320.00

Car Tag (One car)                                           $40.00

 

Total:                                                              $1815.93 (net of current rebates)

 

(Notes: 1) the calculations are based upon the current, first phase of the governments 10 year steady increase in lease rates and service fees for the province’s park cottagers. 2) No attempt is made to correct for different services received in a municipality versus those in a Provincial Park 3) the differential total tax depending on School Tax have been pointed out for illustration only). ”

 

Commentary

 

This data contradicts Ministry claims that Provincial Park cottagers are “privileged” by excessively low rates. The government should be prepared to explain these contradictions. Here are some questions which the Ministry needs to answer.

Since tax rates in the municipal areas are all well under 3%, why is a 4% rate applied to the equivalent Crown land value, especially since the assessed values have increased?

Throughout the Province, municipal and school taxes are calculated on a portioned value, that is, 45% of market value. Why is the crown land rent calculated on the full market value rather than on a portioned value common in municipal areas?

Since the government is making a point of “fairness and comparability” how will they justify the dramatic inflation of cottage rates in Provincial Parks compared to similar regions after the full ten year implementation of the proposed increases when Parks tax rates will be far out of line with taxation rates in any other municipal jurisdictions?

 

We have been unable to obtain answers to these straightforward questions, despite the Ministry and Premier promising transparency, as well as fairness.

Lessees should urgently arrange to meet with their local MLA to get help finding answers to these questions and a solution to the question of fairness in cottage occupancy costs. It is the job of all MLA’s, whether of the government or not, to help constituents get answers to important questions of this kind.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

One response to “Cottage Cost Comparisons”

  1. Allan Smuttell says:

    I fully support your effort to fight this government on this tax increase. I would be willing to make a donation towards the expense of this battle. I don’t know if this has been suggested before or not but if 2000 cottage owners would throw in $ 100.00 each we could put up a battle with some pretty negative media/newspaper publicity. Think back a year or so when the Assiniboine Race Track group put the heat on the government. Thank you. Allan Smuttell

Leave a Reply

All News Categories

Mike Epp – “West Hawk Lake this morning…” (Sunday) ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook
The North Whiteshell Trails Association still needs a few more volunteers to fill board positions. (a few did step forward in our call for volunteers last week). One or two hours per month of your time, and the formation of a board, will open access to funding possibilities, provide oversight of the trails, & ensure the trails are the best they can be (and improved). Cottagers, seasonal campers, other trail lovers, anyone that loves our Park – please help.Email the North Whiteshell Trails Association at (DJ Seales) dj.seales@gmail.com or message me here on our Facebook page & I’ll pass your information on (I know DJ well & he’s very easy to work with)More information can also be found at whiteshellcottagers.com/whiteshell_news/trail-volunteers-stewards-caretakers-needed/Coincidently maybe you saw the front page story in the Sunday Winnipeg Free Press that starts with…..“Nature prescription could be just what the doctor ordered”“TAKE a hike in the forest and call me in the morning”.“Instead of prescribing just a pill or ointment, doctors could soon tell patients to head to the great outdoors.” ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook
Char Baert – “seen at Opapiskaw.” ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook
Falcon cottager (South shore blk 13) sent us the attached. Says it looks like soap. Anyone know what it might be? (coming in from the north) ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook

Recent Instagram Posts